Jane Jarrow

Jane Jarrow

About me

Activity

Discussion Comment

Toshsa, Hmmm... this time I have to disagree. The evidence indicates that if the student does not have a disability, the extended time does not make a signficant difference (if you don't know the answer, all the extra time in the world won't help!). For the student with a disability, who needs more time to respond, the extra time matters. But we don't provide it because we are making it up to them for their disadvantage (because we feel sorry for them). We provide the extra time so that they will have the (equivalent) SAME amount of time that everyone… >>>

Discussion Comment
Toshsa, Missing details -- that's an important one that most folks miss. Everyone recognizes that the individual may have difficulty maintaining attention (the problem itself), but not everyone recognizes the IMPACT of that difficulty. Dr. Jane Jarrow
Toshsa, That's exactly right. Students with disabilities have the right to succeed -- OR fail -- just as other students do. Dr. Jane Jarrow
Discussion Comment
Karen, This is an absolutely TERRIFIC example of how folks traditional thinking (that all culinary arts grads will be on the line) can lead to unintended, but very real, restrictions on the opportunities of students with disabilities. THANKS for providing a first hand testimonial to free thinking. Dr. Jane Jarrow
Discussion Comment

James, The field of rehabilitation engineering is all about redesign of the environment (largely, the equipment available within that environment) to allow people with disabilities to accomplish the same things in different ways. Whether it is fixing an automobile minus a few fingers, or driving a tractor minus an arm or a leg, or a great deal inbetween doesn't mater. You are right. Once someone has successfully entered a field of endeavor, we have no problems dealing with the idea that if something happens to limit that individual, we can and should make adjustments so that they can continue. Then… >>>

Discussion Comment
Viviana, You SHOULDN'T be giving everyone extra time. In doing so, you not only defeat the purpose of the accommodation, but you create legal problems for yourself and for the institution should the student choose to challenge that decision. The extra time is calculated on the basis of how much time everyone else is given. If you give everyone 60 minutes, then the student with the disability may get (for example) 90 minutes. and if you give EVERYONE 90 minutes (in the mistaken belief that it makes things even), then the student with the disability should get 135 minutes. Dr. Jane Jarrow
Discussion Comment
Viviana, I know it is easy to say from a distance, but that is HIS problem, not yours. You did the right thing in demanding the same level of performance from this student as from all the others (the same, not more). Stick to your guns! Dr. Jane Jarrow
Viviana, I am glad your institution has resource people available to you, as an instructor, to help in in determining your role and your obligation (and the limits!) to students with disabilities. Just remember that the students who complain or misread the situation are not ALL the students with disabilities in your classes. Don't let the inappropriate demands of a few color your view of the rest. Dr. Jane Jarrow

Wow. Your post is full of so many generalizations, stereotypes, and opinions stated as fact that I really don't know where to begin, Rommel. You may have the medical background to be discussing the benefits of medication in the manner you do here, but I would venture to guess that your job description at the institution does not include USING such medical expertise to involve yourself in monitoring the health status of your students. I would be very careful, if I were you, about overstepping your bounds. This has little to do with disability, and a great deal to do… >>>

Discussion Comment
Timothy, My daughter has cerebral palsy and uses a wheelchair. When she was in grade school and all the other kids were playing soccer, I set her up with the coach to serve as a kind of "team trainer." She was responsible for keeping the stats, keeping track of uniforms and equipment, and so on. She hated it! GRIN She couldn't figure out why she needed to be out there in the hot sun when she couldn't run up and down the sidelines with the rest of 'em! I am glad your story had a happier ending. Dr. Jane Jarrow

End of Content

End of Content