Synchronous Discussion
Just as the EL 102 lesson mentioned, I also do not agree with synchronous discussion. When I was in grad school, I took a Communication course and it was only online. We participated in synchronous chats through Yahoo Messenger and there were a total of 5 students in the class. There was 1 student that outperformed everyone else and brought down the morale of the class. There were also international students that could not keep up with the content.
I realize this had something to do with the instructor's teaching style, but I have to say it was the worst class I ever had, and ever since, I have had a negative view about synchronous discussion.
Has anyone had a positive experience with synchronous discussion?
Christian,
I too do not agree with synchronous discussion. I am an instructor at a hands on technical school. My students learn mostly by "doing". I feel that my most of my students would not be able to keep up with the fast typers. Which would then make them feel like they are behind in the discussion etc. Anyone else out there have a positive experience with synchronous discussion?
Christin,
I have had success with synchronous discussions. As with anything, it takes time to optimize your use of this tool. You have to make sure all students participate, that one is not dominating discussion, and there is organization to the discussion. It is just one more tool that can be used effectively or ineffectively.
Herbert Brown III
