You bring up a couple of good points about the energy level that can be achieved with real-time chat and the convenience of asynchronous discussion. The question that keeps running through my mind, however, is "which method is best for learning?" Chat is energetic but what about the slow typist or the slow reader? Discussion forums are convenient but does the lack of timely feedback hinder the learning process? As always, I am interested in your thoughts. It seems that you have a great deal of experience with both types of discussion. :)
Jane
