Yes, consistency is a goal of fairness and professionalism towards each student, while dealing with the many unique variables presented in each class, due to different personalities, life situations and needs of the student. It's always a challenge.
I want to improve my use of on-line teaching tools precisely for the above reason. As I see certain students struggling with class requirements, I can encourage them to use the on-line resources, and they can do so more on their own terms than just in the physical classroom environment.