Jane Jarrow

Jane Jarrow

About me

Activity

Discussion Comment
Cambria, You are right. We allow students without disabilities to make their own decisions (and sometimes to make their own mistakes!). We need to allow students with disabilities the same dignity -- and control -- in their lives. Dr. Jane Jarrow

You are right on target here, Cambria. QWERTY keyboards were designed as they are because someone figured out the most efficient to have the letters that are used most often in the place where they can be reached more easily. Nowadays we never even think about the fact that when someone talks about "the keyboard" we all immediately know what they are referring to and what order the letters will be in, so that we can sit down at ANY keyboard, even if you've never seen the computer, and type. Let's take it one step further. What about common FUNCTIONS… >>>

Good examples, Gary! And you are right -- many of the things that we could provide as accommodations for individuals with disabilities are really useful to the broader population, disabled or not. THAT is what Universal Design is all about. Dr. Jane Jarrow
Discussion Comment
Gary, I can't argue with that. Neither would Michaelangelo (who, I understand, had an army of people working under this direction)... or Walt Disney, whose creative genius changed our world (but who didn't do it all himself!). By the way -- did you know that Walt Disney had a learning disability? His creativity and outside-the-box thinking was one of the ways that he focused on his strengths, rather than his weaknesses! Dr. Jane Jarrow
Discussion Comment
Delmar, I do get your point -- and you seem to get mine! "Each according to their need" is what it is all about, and it is illogical to suggest that if everyone doesn't have the SAME circumstances, they don't have EQUAL opportunity. The others don't need Braille or sign language -- OR extended time! Dr. Jane Jarrow
Discussion Comment
Then you need to go back and think it through again, Barney. Besides the fact that formal testing in a limited time period generally had little direct translation to the world of work, it doesn't make a lot of sense to suggest that because people in the workplace have time limits, people in college shouldn't be allowed to enter the world of work -- and that is essentially what you suggest when you say it is "unfair" to others to allow students with disabilities necessary extra time on tests. Dr. Jane Jarrow
Discussion Comment
Delmar, That's a very interesting perspective. I like the idea of trying to help a student with a (potential) limitation find a way to make it work for them. Dr. Jane Jarrow
Discussion Comment
Delmar, I am not sure what a "search tech" is, so you may be right on target in saying it is an unrealistic choice. And I am always in favor of being honest. BUT... I would be careful about your approach to all this. It is appropriate to discuss options -- but when you say "suggest another option" is sounds a lot like counseling someone out of the field, and that is not appropriate. Dr. Jane Jarrow
Discussion Comment
Thomas, I don't think you should worry about being honest in the kind of situation you describe. Saying (for example), "Howard Stern is known for his sharp retorts and his ability to argue loudly and clearly with his guests and his critics. Have you thought about how you would handled that kind of demand on your communication skills?", is not a problem Saying,"I think you may be trouble in reaching that goal" is different than saying, "You will never reach that goal. You need to change your major" are two different things. Dr. Jane Jarrow
Discussion Comment

Absolutely. One of the things that most of us don't think about re: technology is that it can be used in so many different ways that it provides tremendous versatility -- and freedom -- for students with disabilities, because they can use it to accomplish their ends in ways that the rest of us may not need. The first month that my daughter had unlimited text messaging on her phone, she sent/received over 3500 messages. For her, it wasn't a texting system. It allowed her to "talk" to anyone she wanted, whenever she wanted. She couldn't yell down the hall… >>>

End of Content

End of Content