Objection to learning groups
Some people simply do not want to be involved in a group. For whatever reason, the, "touchy feely" of it becomes objectionable. I find this situation difficult to overcome and in some cases simply have student that will not actively participate.
Is this an issue of mine?
I agree that this sentiment is loudest from the top students. They might have had negative experiences before with lazy students or did most of the work while others benefited.
On the other hand, they could also be Type A, controlling students. If that's the case, a discussion may be needed to ascertain why they object to group work. Many careers require group/team work, so they may have to practice it in class before they become CEOs.
Michael,
I think the participation grade is a great idea & use that myself in my classes.
Ryan Meers, Ph.D.
I use group learning during instructor guided demos by splitting the class into groups of 4 and guide them through a technical process step by step and reiterating on the key points and skills from the lecture.
I advise my students on day one of the class that group participation is a requirement and is intended to reflect a real work environment and collaboration that is typical in a shop environment with each new model year as we all learn some of the changes made and share with our peers.
I always have a student or two that will not participate and quietly remind them that a portion of their grade is professionalism and lack of participation is a direct reflection on their professionalism.
Dr. Felicia,
this is definitely true & one of the main reasons that I'm a big proponent of using groups.
Dr. Ryan Meers
It is important for students to learn to collaborate with others. In the workplace today, whether one likes it or not, one must collaborate at one point or another with superiors, peers, or subordinates. Hence, an instructor can let the objecting students understand that learning groups prepare them for the real-world.
Clifton,
I would agree that they like to be alone; I do think some group work is profitable as many careers now utilize this method in the workplace.
Dr. Ryan Meers
I have seen from time to time that some of my highest scoring students maintain wanting to be left alone. They perform well being left to discover on their own. Just their method I guess
Thank you for posting! One of my first thoughts was similar..., "How do encourage all to participate in groups?" With many of my group assignments, I see students dividing up the work vs using the assignment as an opportunity to work together-- or just not participating at all. Do you grade the group or have the group grade one another?
jay,
no I can pretty much assure you it's not your issue, this is a common problem. The best thing to do is just continue to emphasize the importance & tie a grade to it if possible.
Dr. Ryan Meers
